Industry-based Guidance on implementing
Climate-related Disclosures
Volume 36—Real Estate
June 2023
IFRS S2
IFRS
® Sustainability Disclosure Standard
International Sustainability Standards Board
This Industry-based Guidance accompanies IFRS S2 Climate related Disclosures (published
June 2023; see separate booklet) and is issued by the International Sustainability
Standards Board (ISSB).
Disclaimer: To the extent permitted by applicable law, the ISSB and the IFRS Foundation
(Foundation) expressly disclaim all liability howsoever arising from this publication or
any translation thereof whether in contract, tort or otherwise to any person in respect of
any claims or losses of any nature including direct, indirect, incidental or consequential
loss, punitive damages, penalties or costs.
Information contained in this publication does not constitute advice and should not be
substituted for the services of an appropriately qualified professional.
© IFRS Foundation 2023
Reproduction and use rights are strictly limited to personal non-commercial use, such as
corporate disclosure.
Any other use, such as – but not limited to – reporting software, investment analysis,
data services and product development is not permitted without written consent. Please
contact the Foundation for further details at sustainability_licensing@ifrs.org.
All rights reserved.
The Foundation has trade marks registered around the world (Marks) including ‘IAS®’,
‘IASB®’, the IASB® logo, ‘IFRIC®’, ‘IFRS®’, the IFRS® logo, ‘IFRS for SMEs®’, the IFRS for SMEs®
logo,
‘International
Accounting
Standards®’,
‘International
Financial
Reporting
Standards®’, the ‘Hexagon Device’, ‘NIIF®’, ‘SIC®’ and SASB®. Further details of the
Foundation’s Marks are available from the Foundation on request.
The Foundation is a not-for-profit corporation under the General Corporation Law of the
State of Delaware, USA and operates in England and Wales as an overseas company
(Company number: FC023235) with its principal office in the Columbus Building, 7
Westferry Circus, Canary Wharf, London, E14 4HD.
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
1
Introduction
This volume is part of the Industry-based Guidance on Implementing IFRS S2 Climate-related
Disclosures. This guidance suggests possible ways to apply some of the disclosure requirements in
IFRS S2 but does not create additional requirements.
This volume suggests possible ways to identify, measure and disclose information about
climate-related risks and opportunities that are associated with particular business
models, economic activities and other common features that characterise participation in
this industry.
This industry-based guidance has been derived from Sustainability Accounting Standards
Board (SASB) Standards, which are maintained by the International Sustainability
Standards Board (ISSB). The metric codes used in SASB Standards have been included for
ease of reference. For additional context regarding the industry-based guidance contained
in this volume, including structure and terminology, application and illustrative
examples, refer to Section III of the Accompanying Guidance to IFRS S2.
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
2
© IFRS Foundation
Volume 36—Real Estate
Industry Description
Real Estate industry entities own, develop and operate income-producing real estate
assets. Entities in this industry commonly are structured as real estate investment trusts
(REITs) and operate in a wide range of real estate industry segments, including
residential, retail, office, health care, industrial and hotel properties. REITs typically
participate in direct real estate asset ownership, thereby providing investors with the
opportunity to obtain real estate exposure without direct asset ownership and
management. Although REITs often concentrate on individual Real Estate industry
segments, many REITs diversify investments across multiple property types.
Sustainability Disclosure Topics & Metrics
Table 1. Sustainability Disclosure Topics & Metrics
TOPIC
METRIC
CATEGORY
UNIT OF
MEASURE
CODE
Energy
Management
Energy consumption data coverage as
a percentage of total floor area, by
property sector
Quantitative
Percentage
(%) by floor
area
IF-RE-130a.1
(1) Total energy consumed by portfolio
area with data coverage, (2) percentage
grid electricity and (3) percentage
renewable, by property sector
Quantitative
Gigajoules
(GJ),
Percentage
(%)
IF-RE-130a.2
Like-for-like percentage change in
energy consumption for the portfolio
area with data coverage, by property
sector
Quantitative
Percentage
(%)
IF-RE-130a.3
Percentage of eligible portfolio that
(1) has an energy rating and (2) is
certified to ENERGY STAR, by property
sector
Quantitative
Percentage
(%) by floor
area
IF-RE-130a.4
Description of how building energy
management considerations are
integrated into property investment
analysis and operational strategy
Discussion
and Analysis
n/a
IF-RE-130a.5
continued...
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
3
...continued
TOPIC
METRIC
CATEGORY
UNIT OF
MEASURE
CODE
Water
Management
Water withdrawal data coverage as a
percentage of (1) total floor area and
(2) floor area in regions with High or
Extremely High Baseline Water Stress,
by property sector
Quantitative
Percentage
(%) by floor
area
IF-RE-140a.1
(1) Total water withdrawn by portfolio
area with data coverage and
(2) percentage in regions with High or
Extremely High Baseline Water Stress,
by property sector
Quantitative
Thousand
cubic metres
(m³),
Percentage
(%)
IF-RE-140a.2
Like-for-like percentage change in water
withdrawn for portfolio area with data
coverage, by property sector
Quantitative
Percentage
(%)
IF-RE-140a.3
Description of water management risks
and discussion of strategies and
practices to mitigate those risks
Discussion
and Analysis
n/a
IF-RE-140a.4
Management
of Tenant
Sustainability
Impacts
(1) Percentage of new leases that
contain a cost recovery clause for
resource efficiency-related capital
improvements and (2) associated
leased floor area, by property sector
Quantitative
Percentage
(%) by floor
area, Square
metres (m²)
IF-RE-410a.1
Percentage of tenants that are
separately metered or submetered for
(1) grid electricity consumption and
(2) water withdrawals, by property
sector
Quantitative
Percentage
(%) by floor
area
IF-RE-410a.2
Discussion of approach to measuring,
incentivising and improving
sustainability impacts of tenants
Discussion
and Analysis
n/a
IF-RE-410a.3
Climate
Change
Adaptation
Area of properties located in 100-year
flood zones, by property sector
Quantitative
Square
metres (m²)
IF-RE-450a.1
Description of climate change risk
exposure analysis, degree of systematic
portfolio exposure, and strategies for
mitigating risks
Discussion
and Analysis
n/a
IF-RE-450a.2
Table 2. Activity Metrics
ACTIVITY METRIC
CATEGORY
UNIT OF
MEASURE
CODE
Number of assets, by property sector 49
Quantitative
Number
IF-RE-000.A
continued...
49
Note to IF-RE-000.A – Number of assets shall include the number of distinct real estate property
or building assets and is aligned with the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide.
Number of assets shall be disclosed separately for each portion of the entity’s portfolio where
properties are classified into sectors that are aligned with the FTSE Nareit Classification
Structure. The total number of assets reported across all sectors can exceed the actual number
of assets due to the fact that mixed-use assets can be reported in multiple sectors.
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
4
© IFRS Foundation
...continued
ACTIVITY METRIC
CATEGORY
UNIT OF
MEASURE
CODE
Leasable floor area, by property sector 50
Quantitative
Square
metres (m²)
IF-RE-000.B
Percentage of indirectly managed assets, by property
sector 51
Quantitative
Percentage
(%) by floor
area
IF-RE-000.C
Average occupancy rate, by property sector 52
Quantitative
Percentage
(%)
IF-RE-000.D
Energy Management
Topic Summary
Real estate assets consume significant amounts of energy for space heating, ventilating,
air conditioning, water heating, lighting and using equipment and appliances. The type
and magnitude of energy used and strategies for energy management are dependent
upon the real estate asset class, among other factors. Generally, grid electricity is the
predominant form of consumed energy, though on-site fuel combustion and renewable
energy production also serve important roles. Energy costs may be borne by entities or
property occupants; either way, energy management is a significant industry issue. To
the extent that the real estate owner assumes direct responsibility for energy costs, such
costs often represent significant operating costs, indicating the importance of energy
management. Energy pricing volatility and a general trend of electricity price increases,
energy-related regulations, potentially wide variations in energy performance in existing
building stock, and opportunities for efficiency improvements through economically
attractive capital investments all show the importance of energy management. Energy
costs assumed by occupants, either in whole or in part, are nonetheless likely to affect
entities through various channels. Building energy performance is a notable driver of
tenant demand, because it allows them to control operating costs, mitigate potential
environmental impacts, and, often just as importantly, maintain a reputation for
resource conservation. Additionally, real estate owners may be exposed to energy-related
regulations even if energy costs are the occupants’ responsibility. Overall, entities that
effectively manage asset energy performance may realise reduced operating costs and
regulatory risks, as well as increased tenant demand, rental rates and occupancy rates—
all of which drive revenue and asset value appreciation. Improving energy performance is
50
Note to IF-RE-000.B – Leasable floor area shall be disclosed separately for each portion of the
entity’s portfolio where properties are classified into sectors that are aligned with the FTSE
Nareit Classification Structure. Number of units may be used in place of floor area in the
Apartments and Lodging/Resorts property sectors when floor area is not available.
51
Note to IF-RE-000.C –The definition of “indirectly managed assets” is solely based on the
landlord/tenant relationship and is aligned with the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment
Reference Guide: “Where a single tenant has the sole authority to introduce and implement
operating and/or environmental policies and measures, the tenant should be assumed to have
operational control, so [the asset] should be considered to be an Indirectly Managed Asset.”
Percentage of indirectly managed assets shall be disclosed separately for each portion of the
entity’s portfolio where properties are classified into sectors that are aligned with the FTSE
Nareit Classification Structure.
52
Note to IF-RE-000.D – Average occupancy rate shall be disclosed separately for each portion of
the entity’s portfolio where properties are classified into sectors that are aligned with the FTSE
Nareit Classification Structure.
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
5
dependent upon property type and location, target tenant market, local building codes,
physical and legal opportunities to deploy distributed renewable energy, the ability to
measure consumption, and existing building stock, among other factors.
Metrics
IF-RE-130a.1. Energy consumption data coverage as a percentage of total floor
area, by property sector
1
The entity shall disclose the percentage of its portfolio, based on total gross floor
area, with complete energy consumption data coverage.
1.1
Gross floor area is defined as the total property area in square metres,
measured between the principal exterior surfaces of the enclosing fixed
walls of the building(s).
1.1.1
Leasable floor area may be used in place of gross floor area if gross
floor area is not available for the relevant area of the portfolio (for
example, a building with an unknown gross floor but a known
leasable floor area).
1.1.2
Number of units may be used in place of floor area in the
Apartments and Lodging/Resorts property sectors.
1.2
Floor area is considered to have complete energy consumption data
coverage when the entity obtains energy consumption data (for example,
energy types and amounts consumed) for all types of energy consumed in
the relevant floor area during the reporting period, regardless of when
such data was obtained.
1.2.1
If such data is unavailable for one or more types of energy
consumed, the relevant floor area shall be considered to have
incomplete energy consumption data coverage.
1.3
The percentage shall be calculated as the portfolio gross floor area with
complete energy consumption data coverage divided by the total portfolio
gross floor area for which energy is used.
1.4
The scope of energy consumption includes energy from all sources,
including energy purchased from sources external to the entity and its
tenants, and energy produced by the entity or its tenants (self-generated).
For example, direct fuel use, purchased electricity and heating, cooling
and steam energy are all included within the scope of energy
consumption.
2
The entity shall disclose energy consumption data coverage separately for each
property type in its portfolio, where properties are classified into sectors aligned
with the FTSE EPRA Nareit Global Real Estate Index property sector classification
system.
3
The entity may discuss the data coverage comprehensiveness if there are coverage
variations by energy type. For example, if a portion of floor area consumes
electricity and natural gas and the entity has energy consumption data coverage
for electricity but not natural gas, the entity has incomplete energy consumption
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
6
© IFRS Foundation
data coverage. However, the entity may disclose the portion of total portfolio
gross floor area that has partial energy consumption data coverage.
4
The entity may describe energy consumption data coverage variations, including
the factors that influence them.
4.1
Variations in energy consumption data coverage may occur based on
distinctions which may include:
4.1.1
Base Building, Tenant Space and Whole Building
4.1.2
Energy Purchased by the Landlord and energy Purchased by
Tenants
4.1.3
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets
4.1.4
Geographical markets
4.2
Relevant factors that influence energy consumption data coverage may
include:
4.2.1
Geographical markets and the applicable enabling or inhibiting
laws, regulations and policies within such markets, including
utilities policies
4.2.2
Administrative
or
logistical
barriers
to
obtaining
energy
consumption data (for example, lack of integration of utilities’ data
reporting systems)
4.2.3
Tenant demands around privacy or the proprietary nature of
energy consumption data
4.2.4
Property sectors or other more nuanced classifications of property
types
4.2.5
Lease structures, including the length of leases, access to energy
consumption data by the entity, and the entity's ability to
influence energy management performance of Tenant Spaces
4.2.6
The entity’s belief that obtaining Tenant Space energy consumption
data may negatively impact tenant demand
5
The following terms are defined according to the 2018 GRESB Real Estate
Assessment Reference Guide:
5.1
Base Building is defined as the energy consumed in supplying central
building services to lettable/leasable areas and common areas.
5.2
Tenant Space is defined as the lettable floor area (both vacant and let/
leased areas) that is, or can be, occupied by tenants.
5.3
Whole Building is defined as the energy used by tenants and Base Building
services to lettable/leasable and common spaces. This should include all
energy supplied to the building for the operation of the building and the
tenant space.
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
7
5.4
Purchased by Landlord is defined as the energy purchased by the landlord
but consumed by the tenant. This can include energy purchased by the
landlord but used for vacant space.
5.5
Purchased by Tenant is defined as the energy purchased by the tenant.
Typically, this is data outside the entity's immediate control.
5.6
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets are defined as follows: ‘This
definition of Managed assets and the definition of Indirectly Managed
assets are solely based on the landlord/tenant relationship. [Managed and
Indirectly Managed Assets are] assets or buildings for which the landlord is
determined to have ‘operational control’, where operational control is
defined as having the ability to introduce and implement operating and/or
environmental policies and measures. In case both the landlord and tenant
have the authority to introduce and implement any or all the policies
mentioned above, the asset or building should be reported as a Managed
asset. Where a single tenant has the sole authority to introduce and
implement operating and/or environmental policies and measures, the
tenant should be assumed to have operational control, so it should be
considered to be an Indirectly Managed asset.’
6
The entity shall consider the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide
as a normative reference, thus any updates made year-on-year shall be considered
updates to this guidance.
IF-RE-130a.2. (1) Total energy consumed by portfolio area with data coverage,
(2) percentage grid electricity and (3) percentage renewable, by property sector
1
The entity shall disclose (1) total energy consumption by the portfolio area for
which energy consumption data coverage is available as an aggregate figure, in
gigajoules (GJ) or their multiples, where:
1.1
The scope of disclosure includes all property area in the entity’s portfolio
for which energy consumption data coverage is available, regardless of
whether the Tenant Space or Base Building consumes the energy
(including outdoor, exterior and parking areas) and which party pays for
energy expenses.
1.2
The scope of disclosure excludes the portion of energy consumed by the
portfolio area for which energy consumption data is unavailable.
1.2.1
If energy consumption data is unavailable for Tenant Space or
Whole Building for a property but is available for the Base
Building, then the entity shall disclose this energy consumption
data.
1.3
The scope of energy consumption includes energy from all sources,
including energy purchased from sources external to the entity and its
tenants, and energy produced by the entity or its tenants (self-generated).
For example, direct fuel use, purchased electricity, and heating, cooling
and steam energy all are included within the scope of energy
consumption.
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
8
© IFRS Foundation
1.4
In calculating energy consumption from fuels and biofuels, the entity shall
use higher heating values (HHV), also known as gross calorific values
(GCV), which are directly measured or taken from the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).
2
The entity shall disclose (2) the percentage of energy consumed that was supplied
from grid electricity.
2.1
The percentage shall be calculated as purchased grid electricity
consumption divided by total energy consumption.
3
The entity shall disclose (3) the percentage of energy it consumed that was
renewable energy.
3.1
Renewable energy is defined as energy from sources that are replenished
at a rate greater than or equal to their rate of depletion, such as
geothermal, wind, solar, hydro and biomass.
3.2
The percentage shall be calculated as renewable energy consumed divided
by total energy consumed.
3.3
The scope of renewable energy includes renewable fuel the entity
consumed, renewable energy the entity directly produced and renewable
energy the entity purchased, if purchased through a renewable power
purchase agreement (PPA) that explicitly includes renewable energy
certificates (RECs) or Guarantees of Origin (GOs), a Green‐e Energy
Certified utility or supplier program, or other green power products that
explicitly include RECs or GOs, or for which Green‐e Energy Certified RECs
are paired with grid electricity.
3.3.1
For any renewable electricity generated on-site, any RECs and GOs
must be retained (not sold) and retired or cancelled on behalf of the
entity for the entity to claim them as renewable energy.
3.3.2
For renewable PPAs and green power products, the agreement
must explicitly include and convey that RECs and GOs be retained
or replaced and retired or cancelled on behalf of the entity for the
entity to claim them as renewable energy.
3.3.3
The renewable portion of the electricity grid mix that is outside of
the control or influence of the entity is excluded from the scope of
renewable energy.
3.4
For the purposes of this disclosure, the scope of renewable energy from
biomass sources is limited to: materials certified to a third-party standard
(for example, Forest Stewardship Council, Sustainable Forest Initiative,
Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification, or American Tree
Farm System), materials considered eligible sources of supply according to
the Green-e Framework for Renewable Energy Certification, Version 1.0 (2017) or
Green-e regional standards, or materials eligible for an applicable
jurisdictional renewable portfolio standard.
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
9
4
The entity shall apply conversion factors consistently for all data reported under
this disclosure, such as the use of HHVs for fuel usage (including biofuels) and
conversion of kilowatt hours (kWh) to GJ (for energy data, including electricity
from solar or wind energy).
5
Energy consumption data shall be disclosed by (a) Base Building and (b) Tenant
Space, or (c) Whole Building, or a combination of these.
6
The entity shall disclose (1) total energy consumption, (2) percentage grid
electricity, and (3) percentage renewable energy, separately for each property type
in its portfolio where properties are classified into sectors aligned with the FTSE
EPRA Nareit Global Real Estate Index property sector classification system.
7
The entity may describe the variations in energy consumption.
7.1
Variations in energy consumption data coverage may occur based on
distinctions which may include:
7.1.1
Base Building, Tenant Space and Whole Building
7.1.2
Energy Purchased by the Landlord and energy Purchased by
Tenants
7.1.3
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets
7.1.4
Geographical markets
8
The following terms are defined according to the 2018 GRESB Real Estate
Assessment Reference Guide:
8.1
Base Building is defined as the energy consumed in supplying central
building services to lettable/leasable areas and common areas.
8.2
Tenant Space is defined as the lettable floor area (both vacant and let/
leased areas) that is, or can be, occupied by tenants.
8.3
Whole Building is defined as the energy used by tenants and Base Building
services to lettable/leasable and common spaces. This should include all
energy supplied to the building for the operation of the building and the
tenant space.
8.4
Purchased by Landlord is defined as the energy purchased by the landlord
but consumed by the tenant. This can include energy purchased by the
landlord but used for vacant space.
8.5
Purchased by Tenant is defined as the energy purchased by the tenant.
Typically, this is data outside the entity's immediate control.
8.6
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets are defined as follows: ‘This
definition of Managed assets and the definition of Indirectly Managed
assets are solely based on the landlord/tenant relationship. [Managed and
Indirectly Managed Assets are] assets or buildings for which the landlord is
determined to have ‘operational control’, where operational control is
defined as having the ability to introduce and implement operating and/or
environmental policies and measures. In case both the landlord and tenant
have the authority to introduce and implement any or all the policies
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
10
© IFRS Foundation
mentioned above, the asset or building should be reported as a Managed
asset. Where a single tenant has the sole authority to introduce and
implement operating and/or environmental policies and measures, the
tenant should be assumed to have operational control, so it should be
considered to be an Indirectly Managed asset.’
9
The entity shall consider the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide
as a normative reference, thus any updates made year-on-year shall be considered
updates to this guidance.
IF-RE-130a.3. Like-for-like percentage change in energy consumption for the
portfolio area with data coverage, by property sector
1
The entity shall disclose the like-for-like percentage change in energy
consumption for the portfolio area with data coverage.
1.1
The percentage shall be calculated as energy consumed in the reporting
period divided by the energy consumed in the immediately prior reporting
period minus one.
1.2
The scope of energy consumption included in the calculation shall be
aligned with the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide
(‘Like-for-like Comparison’) as including all energy consumed by properties
in the entity’s portfolio for both the full reporting period and the
immediately prior full reporting period.
1.2.1
Energy consumed by properties acquired, sold, under development
or have undergone a major renovation during the reporting period
or the immediately prior reporting period shall be excluded.
1.2.2
No correction for changes in the occupancy rate is needed and
properties with a high variation in vacancy rates shall be included.
1.2.3
If energy consumption data coverage is unavailable for either (or
both) the reporting period or the immediately prior reporting
period, the energy consumed by that relevant portfolio floor area is
excluded from the numerator and the denominator in the
calculation.
2
The scope, methodology and calculations of energy consumption shall be
consistent with IF-RE-130a.2.
3
Like-for-like change in energy consumption shall be disclosed by (a) Base Building
and (b) Tenant Space, or (c) Whole Building, or a combination of these.
3.1
If like-for-like change in energy consumption data is not available for
Tenant Space or Whole Building for a property but is available for the Base
Building, then the entity shall disclose this like-for-like change in energy
consumption data.
4
The entity shall disclose like-for-like change in energy consumption separately for
each property type in its portfolio where properties are classified into sectors
aligned with the FTSE EPRA Nareit Global Real Estate Index property sector
classification system.
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
11
5
The entity may disclose the floor area, in square metres, included in the scope of
like-for-like percentage change in energy consumption if the scope significantly
diverges from the floor area of energy consumption data coverage.
6
Like-for-like data collection, analysis and disclosure may be consistent with the
approach with which the entity discloses its financial reporting data.
6.1
If the entity discloses its financial reporting data using a concept and
methodology similar to ‘Like-for-like Comparison’, the entity shall describe
divergences between the scope of assets or floor area used in financial
reporting and like-for-like change in energy consumption. For example, if
additional assets are excluded from the like-for-like change in energy
consumption relative to like-for-like financial reporting because of data
coverage limitations, such inconsistencies shall be described.
7
The entity may additionally present like-for-like percentage change in energy
consumption on a normalised basis.
7.1
Normalisation factors and methodologies may include the following,
which are presented in the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference
Guide:
7.1.1
Air conditioning or natural ventilation
7.1.2
Building age
7.1.3
Degree days
7.1.4
Footfall
7.1.5
Occupancy rate
7.1.6
Operational hours
7.1.7
Weather conditions
7.1.8
Other
7.2
If the entity chooses to additionally disclose normalised like-for-like
percentage change in energy consumption, the entity shall provide a brief
description of the normalisation factor and methodology or its use of a
third-party methodology.
8
The entity may describe the variations in like-for-like percentage change in energy
consumption.
8.1
Variations in energy consumption may occur based on distinctions which
may include:
8.1.1
Base Building, Tenant Space and Whole Building
8.1.2
Energy Purchased by the Landlord and energy Purchased by Tenant
8.1.3
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets
8.1.4
Geographical markets
9
The following terms are defined according to the 2018 GRESB Real Estate
Assessment Reference Guide:
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
12
© IFRS Foundation
9.1
Base Building is defined as the energy consumed in supplying central
building services to lettable/leasable areas and common areas.
9.2
Tenant Space is defined as the lettable floor area (both vacant and let/
leased areas) that is, or can be, occupied by tenants.
9.3
Whole Building is defined as the energy used by tenants and base building
services to lettable/leasable and common spaces. This should include all
energy supplied to the building for the operation of the building and the
tenant space.
9.4
Purchased by Landlord is defined as the energy purchased by the landlord
but consumed by the tenant. This may include energy purchased by the
landlord but used for vacant space.
9.5
Purchased by Tenant is defined as the energy purchased by the tenant.
Typically, this is data outside the entity’s immediate control.
9.6
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets are defined as follows: ‘This
definition of Managed assets and the definition of Indirectly Managed
assets are solely based on the landlord/tenant relationship. [Managed and
Indirectly Managed Assets are] assets or buildings for which the landlord is
determined to have ‘operational control’ where operational control is
defined as having the ability to introduce and implement operating and/or
environmental policies and measures. In case both the landlord and tenant
have the authority to introduce and implement any or all the policies
mentioned above, the asset or building should be reported as a Managed
asset. Where a single tenant has the sole authority to introduce and
implement operating and/or environmental policies and measures, the
tenant should be assumed to have operational control, so it should be
considered to be an Indirectly Managed asset.’
10
The entity shall consider the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide
as a normative reference, thus any updates made year-on-year shall be considered
updates to this guidance.
IF-RE-130a.4. Percentage of eligible portfolio that (1) has an energy rating and
(2) is certified to ENERGY STAR, by property sector
1
The entity shall disclose the percentage of the portfolio that has a valid or current
energy rating, by gross floor area, where:
1.1
Gross floor area is defined as the total property square footage, measured
between the principal exterior surfaces of the enclosing fixed walls of the
building(s).
1.2
An energy rating is defined according to the 2018 GRESB Real Estate
Assessment Reference Guide as a scheme that measures the energy
performance of buildings, including schemes solely concerned with
measuring energy efficiency performance as well as cases in which an
energy rating is an element of a broader scheme measuring environmental
performance.
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
13
1.3
The percentage shall be calculated as the portfolio gross floor area that has
an energy rating divided by the total portfolio gross floor area.
1.3.1
The entity may exclude from the denominator the portfolio gross
floor area that is ineligible to receive an energy rating based on the
property sector, location (for example, located in a region in which
energy ratings are unavailable), or other specific use characteristics
that cause the property to be ineligible.
1.4
The scope of energy rating schemes includes:
1.4.1
ENERGY STAR® for operations in the U.S. and Canada
1.4.2
EU Energy Performance Certificates (EPC) for operations in the
European Union
1.4.3
National Australian Built Environment Rating System (NABERS)
Energy for operations in Australia
1.4.4
NABERSNZ for operations in New Zealand
1.4.5
Other energy rating schemes that can be demonstrated to have
substantially equivalent criteria, methodology and presentation of
results as those schemes stated above
1.5
The scope of energy rating schemes is aligned with the 2018 GRESB Real
Estate Assessment Reference Guide in that it ‘only include[s] energy ratings
that were awarded before or during the reporting period (pre-assessments
or other unofficial rating schemes are not valid). Some energy ratings are
valid for a limited period only—the rating should be officially in effect
during the reporting period.’
2
The entity may additionally disclose the percentage(s) by energy rating scheme.
3
The entity shall (2) disclose the percentage of its portfolio certified to ENERGY
STAR®.
3.1
The percentage shall be calculated as the portfolio gross floor area
certified to ENERGY STAR® in the US divided by the total portfolio gross
floor area in the US.
3.1.1
For a property to qualify as certified to ENERGY STAR®, the
certification must be officially in effect during the reporting period
(as aligned with the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference
Guide).
3.1.2
The entity may exclude from the denominator the portfolio gross
floor area that is ineligible to be certified to ENERGY STAR® based
on the property sector or other specific use characteristics that
cause the property to be ineligible.
3.2
If property is located in Canada, the entity may separately disclose the
percentage of the portfolio in Canada that is certified to ENERGY STAR®.
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
14
© IFRS Foundation
3.2.1
The percentage shall be calculated as the portfolio gross floor area
that is certified to ENERGY STAR® in Canada divided by the total
portfolio gross floor area in Canada.
4
The entity shall disclose (1) the percentage of its portfolio that has an energy
rating, and (2) the percentage of its portfolio that is certified to ENERGY STAR®,
separately for each property type in its portfolio where properties are classified
into sectors aligned with the FTSE EPRA Nareit Global Real Estate Index property
sector classification.
5
The entity shall consider the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide
as a normative reference, thus any updates made year-on-year shall be considered
updates to this guidance.
IF-RE-130a.5. Description of how building energy management considerations are
integrated into property investment analysis and operational strategy
1
The entity shall describe its strategic approach and the operational processes used
to integrate energy-related considerations into the analysis of current and future
property investments.
2
The entity shall describe the following elements of its strategic approach, where
relevant:
2.1
The use of energy-reduction targets and performance against those targets
2.2
The integration of property energy performance into the property
acquisition due diligence process—for example, if these measures are
qualitative (for example, whether the building has an energy rating) or
quantitative (for example, the entity adjusts occupancy rate projections
based on energy performance data)
2.3
Entity-level energy consumption and management policies, applicable
across the entity’s portfolio (aligned with 2018 GRESB Real Estate
Assessment Q8)
3
The entity shall discuss the operational processes used, which may include:
3.1
Management of the technical energy performance of its portfolio
3.2
The integration of renewable energy into its portfolio.
4
Relevant elements of its technical approach may include:
4.1
Use of technical building assessments to identify energy efficiency
opportunities—including whether such assessments are in-house or
external and the general portfolio coverage of such assessments during the
last four years (aligned with 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Q16)
4.2
Measures implemented to improve the energy efficiency of the portfolio—
including specific measures taken, general portfolio coverage of such
measures and estimated energy savings (aligned with 2018 GRESB Real
Estate Assessment Q17)
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
15
4.3
Approach to retrocommissioning—including applicability to the entity’s
portfolio, the comprehensiveness of retrocommissioning conducted,
general portfolio coverage and estimated energy savings
4.4
Use of environmental management systems to measure, manage and
improve the energy performance of buildings and such systems’ alignment
with third-party standards or verification (aligned with 2018 GRESB Real
Estate Assessment Q21, ‘Environmental Management Systems’)
4.5
Use of data management systems to monitor, analyse and benchmark
energy performance of individual buildings, and such systems’ alignment
with third-party standards or verification (aligned with 2018 GRESB Real
Estate Assessment Q22, ‘Data Management Systems’)
5
The entity shall discuss its strategies relating to energy ratings, benchmarking
and certifications, including:
5.1
Impact on tenant demand within the entity’s target market(s)
5.2
Relevance to the property types in its portfolio, such as the sector(s),
locations and construction (new versus existing stock)
5.3
Costs and benefits associated with obtaining and maintaining an energy
rating, benchmark and certification
5.4
If applicable, whether the entity prefers certifications based on ongoing
performance or performance-modelled design objectives
6
The entity shall describe its approach to renewable energy generation, which may
include:
6.1
The relevance of on-site and off-site renewable energy generation to the
portfolio and energy management strategy
6.2
Technical or legal limitations on the ability to incorporate renewable
energy into its portfolio and energy management strategy
6.3
The energy generated from on-site and off-site renewable energy (aligned
with 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Q25.3)
7
If the entity participates in new construction or major renovations, it shall discuss
whether and how it incorporates energy efficiency strategies into design and
development.
8
The entity shall consider the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment as a normative
reference, thus any updates made year-on-year shall be considered updates to this
guidance.
Water Management
Topic Summary
Buildings consume significant amounts of water in their operations, through water
fixtures, building equipment, appliances and irrigation. Water consumption operating
costs may be significant depending on property type, tenant operations, geographical
locations and other factors. Entities can be responsible for a building’s water costs, or
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
16
© IFRS Foundation
common area water costs, though entities commonly allocate all, or a portion, of these
costs to occupants. In these arrangements, water management through tenant demand
and regulatory exposure continues to be important. Tenants may assess real estate asset
water efficiency to control operating costs, mitigate environmental impacts of operations,
and, often just as importantly, develop a reputation for resource conservation.
Additionally, real estate owners may comply with water-related regulations even if water
costs are the occupants’ responsibility. Overall, entities that effectively manage asset
water efficiency, even if they bear no direct water costs, may realise reduced operating
costs and regulatory exposure, as well as increased tenant demand, rental rates and
occupancy rates—all of which drive revenue and asset value appreciation. Long-term
historic water expense increases and expectations of continued increases because of
overconsumption and constrained supplies resulting from population growth and shifts,
pollution and climate change show the importance of water management. Improving
asset water efficiency is dependent upon the property type, water availability, target
tenant market, local building codes, the ability to measure consumption and the existing
building stock, among other factors.
Metrics
IF-RE-140a.1. Water withdrawal data coverage as a percentage of (1) total floor
area and (2) floor area in regions with High or Extremely High Baseline Water
Stress, by property sector
1
The entity shall disclose (1) the percentage of its portfolio, based on total gross
floor area, with complete water withdrawal data coverage.
1.1
Gross floor area is defined as the total property area in square metres,
measured between the principal exterior surfaces of the enclosing fixed
walls of the building(s).'
1.1.1
Leasable floor area may be used in place of gross floor area if gross
floor area is unavailable for the relevant area of the portfolio (for
example, a building with an unknown gross floor but a known
leasable floor area).
1.1.2
Number of units may be used in place of floor area in the
Apartments and Lodging/Resorts property sectors.
1.2
Floor area is considered to have complete water withdrawal data coverage
when the entity obtains water withdrawal data (amounts withdrawn) for
the relevant floor area during the reporting period, regardless of when
such data was obtained.
1.3
The percentage shall be calculated as the portfolio gross floor area with
complete water withdrawal data coverage divided by the total portfolio
gross floor area for which water is used.
1.4
The scope of water withdrawals is aligned with the 2018 GRESB Real Estate
Assessment Reference Guide, and it includes water that was withdrawn
from all sources.
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
17
1.4.1
Water sources include surface water (including water from
wetlands, rivers, lakes and oceans), groundwater, rainwater
collected directly and stored by the entity, and water and
wastewater obtained from municipal water supplies, water
utilities, or other entities.
2
The entity shall disclose (2) the percentage of its portfolio, based on gross floor
area, located in regions classified as High (40–80%) or Extremely High (>80%)
Baseline Water Stress with complete water withdrawal data coverage.
2.1
High or Extremely High Baseline Water Stress shall be determined by the
World Resources Institute’s (WRI) Water Risk Atlas tool, Aqueduct.
2.2
The percentage shall be calculated as the portfolio gross floor area located
in regions classified as High or Extremely High Baseline Water Stress and
that have complete water withdrawal data coverage, divided by the total
portfolio gross floor area for which water is used in regions with High or
Extremely High Baseline Water Stress.
3
The entity shall disclose (1) water withdrawal data coverage and (2) the percentage
of water withdrawal data coverage in regions with High or Extremely High
Baseline Water Stress, separately for each property type in its portfolio if
properties are classified into sectors aligned with the FTSE EPRA Nareit Global
Real Estate Index property sector classification.
4
The entity may describe the variations in water withdrawal data coverage,
including the factors that influence it.
4.1
Variations in water withdrawal data coverage may occur based on
distinctions, which may include:
4.1.1
Base Building, Tenant Space and Whole Building
4.1.2
Water Purchased by the Landlord and water Purchased by Tenants
4.1.3
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets
4.1.4
Geographical markets
4.2
Relevant factors that influence water withdrawal data coverage may
include:
4.2.1
Geographical markets and the applicable enabling or inhibiting
laws, regulations and policies within such markets, including those
policies of utilities
4.2.2
Geographical markets and the applicability of risks related to water
scarcity (and related current or future regulations)
4.2.3
Administrative or logistical barriers to obtaining water withdrawal
data (for example, lack of integration of utilities’ data reporting
systems)
4.2.4
Tenant demands around the privacy or proprietary nature of water
withdrawal data
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
18
© IFRS Foundation
4.2.5
Property sectors or other more nuanced classifications of property
types
4.2.6
Lease structures, including the length of leases, access to water
withdrawal data by the entity, and the entity's ability to influence
water management performance of Tenant Spaces
4.2.7
The entity’s belief that obtaining Tenant Space water withdrawal
data may impact tenant demand negatively
5
The following terms are defined according to the 2018 GRESB Real Estate
Assessment Reference Guide:
5.1
Base Building is defined as water consumed in supplying central building
services to lettable/leasable areas and common areas.
5.2
Tenant Space is defined as the lettable floor area (both vacant and let/
leased areas) that is or can be occupied by tenants.
5.3
Whole Building is defined as water used by tenants and base building
services to lettable/leasable and common spaces. This should include all
water supplied to the building for the operation of the building and the
tenant space.
5.4
Purchased by Landlord is defined as water purchased by the landlord but
consumed by the tenant. This may include water purchased by the
landlord but used for vacant space.
5.5
Purchased by Tenant is defined as water purchased by the tenant.
Typically, this is data outside the entity's immediate control.
5.6
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets are defined as follows: ‘This
definition of Managed assets and the definition of Indirectly Managed
assets are solely based on the landlord/tenant relationship. [Managed and
Indirectly Managed Assets are] assets or buildings for which the landlord is
determined to have ‘operational control’ where operational control is
defined as having the ability to introduce and implement operating and/or
environmental policies and measures. In case both the landlord and tenant
have the authority to introduce and implement any or all the policies
mentioned above, the asset or building should be reported as a Managed
asset. Where a single tenant has the sole authority to introduce and
implement operating and/or environmental policies and measures, the
tenant should be assumed to have operational control, so it should be
considered to be an Indirectly Managed asset.’
6
The entity shall consider the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide
as a normative reference, thus any updates made year-on-year shall be considered
updates to this guidance.
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
19
IF-RE-140a.2. (1) Total water withdrawn by portfolio area with data coverage and
(2) percentage in regions with High or Extremely High Baseline Water Stress, by
property sector
1
The entity shall disclose (1) the total amount of water, in thousands of cubic
metres, withdrawn by the portfolio area for which water withdrawal data
coverage is available.
1.1
The scope of disclosure includes all property area in the entity’s portfolio
for which water withdrawal data coverage is available, regardless of
whether water is consumed by the Tenant Space or Base Building
(including outdoor, exterior and parking areas) or which party pays for
water expenses.
1.2
The scope of disclosure excludes the portion of water consumed by the
portfolio area for which water withdrawal data is unavailable.
1.2.1
If water withdrawal data is unavailable for Tenant Space or Whole
Building for a property but is available for the Base Building, then
the entity shall disclose this water withdrawal data.
1.3
The scope of water withdrawals is aligned with the 2018 GRESB Real Estate
Assessment Reference Guide and includes water withdrawn from all
sources.
1.3.1
Water sources include surface water (including water from
wetlands, rivers, lakes and oceans), groundwater, rainwater
collected directly and stored by the entity, and water and
wastewater obtained from municipal water supplies, water utilities
or other entities.
2
The entity shall disclose (2) the percentage of water withdrawn in regions with
High (40–80%) or Extremely High (> 80%) Baseline Water Stress.
2.1
High or Extremely High Baseline Water Stress shall be determined by the
World Resources Institute’s (WRI) Water Risk Atlas tool, Aqueduct.
2.2
The percentage shall be calculated as the amount of water withdrawn (by
volume) in regions with High or Extremely High Baseline Water Stress
divided by the total amount of water withdrawn (by volume).
3
Water withdrawal data shall be disclosed by (a) Base Building and (b) Tenant
Space, or (c) Whole Building, or a combination of these.
4
The entity shall disclose (1) total water withdrawn and (2) percentage in regions
with High or Extremely High Baseline Water Stress, separately for each property
type in its portfolio where properties are classified into sectors aligned with the
FTSE EPRA Nareit Global Real Estate Index property sector classification.
5
The entity may describe the variations in water withdrawn.
5.1
Variations in water withdrawn may occur based on distinctions which
may include:
5.1.1
Base Building, Tenant Space and Whole Building
5.1.2
Water Purchased by the Landlord and water Purchased by Tenant
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
20
© IFRS Foundation
5.1.3
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets
5.1.4
Geographical markets
6
The following terms are defined according to the 2018 GRESB Real Estate
Assessment Reference Guide:
6.1
Base Building is defined as water consumed in supplying central building
services to lettable/leasable areas and common areas.
6.2
Tenant Space is defined as the lettable floor area (both vacant and let/
leased areas) that is or can be occupied by tenants.
6.3
Whole Building is defined as water used by tenants and base building
services to lettable/leasable and common spaces. This should include all
water supplied to the building for the operation of the building and the
tenant space.
6.4
Purchased by Landlord is defined as water purchased by the landlord but
consumed by the tenant. This may include water purchased by the
landlord but used for vacant space.
6.5
Purchased by Tenant is defined as water purchased by the tenant.
Typically, this is data outside the entity's immediate control.
6.6
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets are defined as follows: ‘This
definition of Managed assets and the definition of Indirectly Managed
assets are solely based on the landlord/tenant relationship. [Managed and
Indirectly Managed Assets are] assets or buildings for which the landlord is
determined to have ‘operational control’ where operational control is
defined as having the ability to introduce and implement operating and/or
environmental policies and measures. In case both the landlord and tenant
have the authority to introduce and implement any or all the policies
mentioned above, the asset or building should be reported as a Managed
asset. Where a single tenant has the sole authority to introduce and
implement operating and/or environmental policies and measures, the
tenant should be assumed to have operational control, so it should be
considered to be an Indirectly Managed asset.’
7
The entity shall consider the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide
as a normative reference, thus any updates made year-on-year shall be considered
updates to this guidance.
IF-RE-140a.3. Like-for-like percentage change in water withdrawn for portfolio
area with data coverage, by property sector
1
The entity shall disclose the like-for-like percentage change in water withdrawn
for the portfolio area with data coverage.
1.1
The percentage shall be calculated as water withdrawn (by volume) in the
reporting period divided by the water withdrawn (by volume) in the
immediately prior reporting period minus one.
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
21
1.2
The scope of water withdrawn included in the calculation shall be aligned
with the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide (‘Like-for-
like Comparison’) as including all water withdrawn by properties in the
entity’s portfolio for both the full reporting period and the immediately
prior full reporting period.
1.2.1
Water withdrawn by properties acquired, sold, under development,
or that have undergone a major renovation during the reporting
period or the immediately prior reporting period shall be excluded.
1.2.2
No correction for changes in the occupancy rate is needed and
properties with a high variation in vacancy rates shall be included.
1.2.3
If water withdrawal data coverage is unavailable for either (or both)
the reporting period or the immediately prior reporting period, the
water withdrawn by that relevant portfolio floor area is excluded
from the numerator and the denominator in the calculation.
2
The scope, methodology and calculations of water withdrawn shall be consistent
with IF-RE-140a.2.
3
Like-for-like change in water withdrawn shall be disclosed by (a) Base Building and
(b) Tenant Space, or (c) Whole Building, or a combination of these.
3.1
If like-for-like change in water withdrawal data is not available for Tenant
Space or Whole Building for a property but is available for the Base
Building, then the entity shall disclose this like-for-like water withdrawal
data.
4
The entity shall disclose like-for-like percentage change in water withdrawn
separately for each property type in its portfolio where properties are classified
into sectors aligned with the FTSE EPRA Nareit Global Real Estate Index property
sector classification.
5
The entity may disclose the floor area, in square metres, included in the scope of
like-for-like percentage change in water withdrawn if the scope significantly
diverges from the floor area of water withdrawal data coverage.
6
Like-for-like data collection, analysis and disclosure may be consistent with the
approach with which the entity discloses its financial reporting data.
6.1
If the entity discloses its financial reporting data using a concept and
methodology similar to ‘Like-for-like Comparison’, the entity shall describe
divergences between the scope of assets or floor area used in financial
reporting and like-for-like change in water withdrawn. For example, if
additional assets are excluded from the like-for-like change in water
withdrawn relative to like-for-like financial reporting because of data
coverage limitations, such inconsistencies shall be described.
7
The entity may additionally present like-for-like percentage change in water
withdrawn on a normalised basis.
7.1
Normalisation factors and methodologies may include the following which
are presented in the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide:
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
22
© IFRS Foundation
7.1.1
Air conditioning or natural ventilation
7.1.2
Building age
7.1.3
Degree days
7.1.4
Footfall
7.1.5
Occupancy rate
7.1.6
Operational hours
7.1.7
Weather conditions
7.1.8
Other
7.2
If the entity chooses to additionally disclose normalised like-for-like
percentage change in water withdrawn, the entity shall provide a brief
description of the normalisation factor and methodology or its use of a
third-party methodology.
8
The entity may describe the variations in like-for-like percentage change in water
withdrawn.
8.1
Variations in water withdrawn may occur based on distinctions which
may include:
8.1.1
Base Building, Tenant Space and Whole Building
8.1.2
Water Purchased by the Landlord and water Purchased by Tenant
8.1.3
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets
8.1.4
Geographical markets
9
The following terms are defined according to the 2018 GRESB Real Estate
Assessment Reference Guide:
9.1
Base Building is defined as water consumed in supplying central building
services to lettable/leasable areas and common areas.
9.2
Tenant Space is defined as the lettable floor area (both vacant and let/
leased areas).
9.3
Whole Building is defined as water used by tenants and base building
services to lettable/leasable and common spaces. This should include all
water supplied to the building for the operation of the building and the
tenant space.
9.4
Purchased by Landlord is defined as water purchased by the landlord but
consumed by the tenant. This may include water purchased by the
landlord but used for vacant space.
9.5
Purchased by Tenant is defined as water purchased by the tenant.
Typically, this is data outside the entity's immediate control.
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
23
9.6
Managed Assets and Indirectly Managed Assets are defined as follows: ‘This
definition of Managed assets and the definition of Indirectly Managed
assets are solely based on the landlord/tenant relationship. [Managed and
Indirectly Managed Assets are] assets or buildings for which the landlord is
determined to have ‘operational control’ where operational control is
defined as having the ability to introduce and implement operating and/or
environmental policies and measures. In case both the landlord and tenant
have the authority to introduce and implement any or all the policies
mentioned above, the asset or building should be reported as a Managed
asset. Where a single tenant has the sole authority to introduce and
implement operating and/or environmental policies and measures, the
tenant should be assumed to have operational control, so it should be
considered to be an Indirectly Managed asset.’
10
The entity shall consider the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide
as a normative reference, thus any updates made year-on-year shall be considered
updates to this guidance.
IF-RE-140a.4. Description of water management risks and discussion of
strategies and practices to mitigate those risks
1
The entity shall describe its water management risks associated with water
withdrawals, water consumption and discharge of water or wastewater.
1.1
Risks associated with water withdrawals and water consumption include
risks to the availability of adequate, clean water resources, which include:
1.1.1
Environmental constraints—such as operating in water-stressed
regions,
drought,
concerns
of
aquatic
impingement
or
entrainment, interannual or seasonal variability, and risks from
the impact of climate change
1.1.2
Regulatory and financial constraints—such as volatility in water
costs, stakeholder perceptions and concerns related to water
withdrawals (for example, those from local communities, non-
governmental organisations and regulatory agencies), direct
competition with and impact from the actions of other users (for
example, commercial and municipal users), restrictions to
withdrawals because of regulations, and constraints on the entity’s
ability to obtain and retain water rights or permits
1.2
Risks associated with the discharge of water or wastewater include the
ability to obtain rights or permits related to discharges, regulatory
compliance related to discharges, restrictions to discharges, the ability to
maintain control over the temperature of water discharges, liabilities,
reputational risks and increased operating costs because of regulation,
stakeholder perceptions and concerns related to water discharges (for
example, those from local communities, non-governmental organisations
and regulatory agencies).
2
The entity may describe water management risks in the context of:
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
24
© IFRS Foundation
2.1
How risks may vary by withdrawal source, including surface water
(including water from wetlands, rivers, lakes and oceans), groundwater,
rainwater collected directly and stored by the entity, and water and
wastewater obtained from municipal water supplies, water utilities or
other entities; and
2.2
How risks may vary by discharge destinations, including surface water,
groundwater or wastewater utilities.
3
The entity may discuss the potential effects that water management risks may
have on its operations and the time line over which such risks are expected to
manifest.
3.1
Effects include those associated with costs, revenue, liabilities, continuity
of operations and reputation.
4
The entity shall discuss its short- and long-term strategies or plans to mitigate
water management risks, which include:
4.1
The scope of its strategy, plans, goals or targets, such as how they relate to
various business units, geographies or water-consuming operational
processes.
4.2
Any water management goals or targets it has prioritised, and an analysis
of performance against those goals or targets.
4.2.1
Goals and targets include those associated with reducing water
withdrawals,
reducing
water
consumption,
reducing
water
discharges, reducing aquatic impingements, improving the quality
of water discharges and regulatory compliance.
4.3
The activities and investments required to achieve the plans, goals or
targets, and any risks or limiting factors that might affect achievement of
the plans or targets.
4.4
Disclosure of strategies, plans, goals or targets shall be limited to activities
that were ongoing (active) or reached completion during the reporting
period.
5
For water management targets, the entity shall additionally disclose:
5.1
Whether the target is absolute or intensity-based, and the metric
denominator if it is an intensity-based target.
5.2
The time lines for the water management activities, including the start
year, the target year and the base year.
5.3
The mechanism(s) for achieving the target, including:
5.3.1
Efficiency efforts, such as the use of water recycling or closed-loop
systems;
5.3.2
Product innovations, such as redesigning products or services to
require less water;
5.3.3
Process and equipment innovations, such as those that enable the
reduction of aquatic impingements or entrainments;
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
25
5.3.4
Use of tools and technologies (for example, the World Wildlife
Fund Water Risk Filter, the Global Water Tool and Water Footprint
Network Footprint Assessment Tool) to analyse water use, risks and
opportunities; and
5.3.5
Collaborations or programmes in place with the community or
other organisations
5.4
The percentage reduction or improvement from the base year, in which
the base year is the first year against which water management targets are
evaluated towards the achievement of the target.
6
The entity shall discuss whether its water management practices result in any
additional lifecycle impacts or trade-offs in its organisation, including trade-offs
in land use, energy production and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and why the
entity chose these practices despite lifecycle trade-offs.
Management of Tenant Sustainability Impacts
Topic Summary
Real estate assets generate significant sustainability impacts, including resource
consumption (energy and water), waste generation and impacts on occupant health
through indoor environmental quality. While entities own real estate assets, the tenant
operations of such assets dominate the sustainability impacts produced by the built
environment. Tenants may design and construct leased spaces according to their
operating needs. In turn, their operations consume significant amounts of energy and
water, generate waste, and impact the health of those living, working, shopping, or
visiting the properties. While these sustainability impacts often are often generated by
tenant operations and activities, real estate owners play an important role in influencing
tenant sustainability impacts. The way entities in the industry structure their
agreements, contracts and relationships with tenants may be instrumental in managing
the sustainability impacts of their tenants effectively, and ultimately, the impacts of their
assets. Managing tenant sustainability impacts may include mitigating the problem of
split incentives by aligning both parties’ financial interests with sustainability outcomes,
establishing systematic measurement and communication of resource consumption data,
creating shared performance goals, and mandating minimum sustainability performance
or design requirements, among other strategies. Effective management of tenant
sustainability impacts, particularly related to energy, water and indoor environmental
quality, may drive asset value appreciation, increase tenant demand and satisfaction,
decrease direct operating costs, or decrease risks related to building codes and
regulations.
Metrics
IF-RE-410a.1. (1) Percentage of new leases that contain a cost recovery clause
for resource efficiency-related capital improvements and (2) associated leased
floor area, by property sector
1
The entity shall disclose (1) the percentage of new leases that contain a cost
recovery clause for resource efficiency-related capital improvements.
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
26
© IFRS Foundation
1.1
A cost recovery clause for resource efficiency-related capital improvements
is defined as a clause in a lease agreement that allows the entity to invest
in energy or water efficiency capital improvements to properties, while
recovering all or a proportion of associated expenditures from tenants,
regardless of the mechanism of cost recovery. This definition is generally
aligned with:
1.1.1
The Green Lease Leaders application: ‘Tenant cost recovery clause
that
can
be
used
for
energy
efficiency-related
capital
improvements. This typically means that the list of operating
expenses is expanded to include capital expenses intended to save
energy, with the annual pass-through amount most often
determined either by an amortisation schedule or projected
savings.’
1.1.2
The 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide: ‘Cost
recovery clause for energy efficiency-related capital improvements:
Allows the landlord to implement energy-efficiency measures
during the lease and to recover a proportion or all of those costs
from the tenant.’
1.2
The percentage shall be calculated as the portfolio newly leased floor area
associated with leases that contain a cost recovery clause for resource
efficiency-related capital improvements divided by total portfolio newly
leased floor area.
1.2.1
Number of units may be used in place of floor area in the
Apartments and Lodging/Resorts property sectors.
2
The entity shall disclose (2) the leased floor area, in square metres, associated with
new leases that contain a cost recovery clause for resource efficiency-related
capital improvements.
3
The scope of disclosure includes all the properties in the entity’s portfolio that
were newly leased during any part of the reporting period, and for which the
entity and a tenant executed an associated lease.
3.1
If the entity executed lease amendments or letter agreements during the
reporting period that contain a cost recovery clause for resource efficiency-
related capital improvements, the associated leased floor area shall be
included within the scope of disclosure.
4
The entity shall disclose (1) the percentage of new leases that contain a cost
recovery clause for resource efficiency-related capital improvements, and (2) the
associated leased floor area, separately for each property type in its portfolio
where properties are classified into sectors aligned with the FTSE EPRA Nareit
Global Real Estate Index property sector classification.
5
The entity may describe whether its standard lease contracts include a cost
recovery clause for resource efficiency-related capital improvements (aligned with
2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Q39).
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
27
6
The entity may additionally disclose the percentage of all leases (as opposed to
new leases only) in effect as of the last day of the reporting period that contain a
cost recovery clause for resource efficiency-related capital improvements,
calculated in a manner consistent with the above calculation.
7
The entity may provide a brief description of instances when it exercised cost
recovery clauses for resource efficiency-related capital improvements, including
the extent throughout the portfolio and the financial implications.
8
The entity additionally may disclose the amount of actual capital expenditures
associated with resource efficiency-related capital improvements recovered from
tenants during the reporting period using cost recovery clauses in leases.
9
The entity shall consider the 2018 GRESB Real Estate Assessment Reference Guide
as a normative reference, thus any updates made year-on-year shall be considered
updates to this guidance.
IF-RE-410a.2. Percentage of tenants that are separately metered or submetered
for (1) grid electricity consumption and (2) water withdrawals, by property sector
1
The entity shall disclose the percentage of tenants separately metered or
submetered for (1) the grid electricity use resulting from their exclusive electricity
consumption.
1.1
The percentage shall be calculated as the leasable floor area leased to
tenants that are separately metered or submetered for the electricity
consumption resulting from their exclusive consumption divided by the
total portfolio leasable floor area.
2
The entity shall disclose the percentage of tenants separately metered or
submetered for (2) the water usage resulting from their exclusive water
withdrawals.
2.1
The percentage shall be calculated as the leasable floor area leased to
tenants that are separately metered or submetered for the water use
resulting from their exclusive withdrawals divided by the total portfolio
leasable floor area.
3
Number of units may be used in place of floor area in the Apartments and
Lodging/Resorts property sectors.
4
The entity shall disclose the percentage of tenants that are separately metered or
submetered for their exclusive (1) grid electricity consumption, and (2) water
withdrawals, separately for each property type in its portfolio where properties
are classified into sectors aligned with the FTSE EPRA Nareit Global Real Estate
Index property sector classification.
IF-RE-410a.3. Discussion of approach to measuring, incentivising and improving
sustainability impacts of tenants
1
The entity shall discuss its strategy and process for integrating considerations of
sustainability into its leases and tenant relationships (for example, tenant
communication, voluntary initiatives and selection of a third-party property
manager, if applicable) to measure, incentivise and improve impacts.
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
28
© IFRS Foundation
2
For the purposes of this disclosure, the scope of sustainability topics includes
energy management, water management and the impacts of properties on tenant
health, including indoor environmental quality.
3
Relevant strategies to discuss may include:
3.1
The following components, which are generally aligned with the 2018
GRESB Real Estate Assessment Q39.1:
3.1.1
Whether the entity has agreements with tenants to mutually share
energy consumption or water withdrawal data
3.1.2
Whether the entity has shared energy consumption and water
withdrawal targets
3.1.3
Whether the entity establishes requirements that any tenant works
should meet standards provided by the entity related to energy
consumption, water efficiency and indoor environmental quality
3.1.4
Whether the entity establishes requirements that tenants provide
accurate information required for mandatory energy rating
schemes
3.1.5
Whether the entity can prioritise sustainability requirements over
minimising the costs of improvements and adjustments
3.2
Whether the entity prioritises separately metering or submetering tenant
energy consumption and water withdrawals, and if so, if the entity also
prioritises its own ability to measure the tenant energy consumption and
water withdrawals
3.3
Whether the entity prioritises lease structures that require tenants to pay
grid electricity and water utility expenses based on actual and exclusive
consumption of such resources
4
The entity shall include a discussion of its support, participation and use of third-
party initiatives concerning green leases.
4.1
Third-party initiatives concerning green leases may include green lease
templates, principles, requirements, strategies and educational programs
provided by organisations.
4.2
Examples of third-party initiatives concerning green leases may include:
4.2.1
Building
Owners
and
Managers
Association
International,
Commercial Lease: Guide to Sustainable and Energy Efficient Leasing for
High-Performance Buildings
4.2.2
California Sustainability Alliance, Green Leases Toolkit
4.2.3
CMS, Green Lease Clauses in Europe - A practical approach
4.2.4
Corporate Realty, Design & Management Institute, Model Green Lease
4.2.5
Green Lease Leaders and Green Lease Library (programs jointly
operated by the Institute for Market Transformation and the U.S.
Department of Energy’s Better Building Alliance)
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
29
4.2.6
Natural Resources Defence Council, Energy Efficiency Lease Guidance
4.2.7
Real Property Association of Canada, Green Office Leases
4.2.8
U.S. General Services Administration, Green Lease Policies and
Procedures
4.2.9
U.S. Green Building Council, Green Office Guide: Integrating LEED into
Your Leasing Process and Greening Your Lease
4.3
The entity shall describe whether third-party initiatives concerning green
leases are integrated into standard lease contracts (generally aligned with
GRESB Real Estate Assessment Q39.1).
5
The entity shall describe how the lease types used (for example, triple-net or full-
service) and their provisions (for example, cost recovery clauses, tenant fit out
guides, utility information sharing, mandatory participation in energy ratings)
may influence or incentivise tenant behaviour related to sustainability impacts.
5.1
The entity may provide a discussion of how such lease structures may
impact property values—including tenant demand and the associated
rental rates and occupancy rates—over the long term.
Climate Change Adaptation
Topic Summary
Climate change affects entities in the industry via frequent or high-impact extreme
weather events and changing climate patterns. How an entity structures its business
model to incorporate assessments of climate change risks, and the adaptation to such
risks, may increasingly be relevant to entity value over the long-term. More specifically,
investment strategies with assets located on floodplains and in coastal regions exposed to
inclement weather may require increased risk mitigation and business model adaptation
to long-term climate change. These strategies are especially important considering the
long-term challenges associated with flood insurance rates, the financial stability of
government-subsidised flood insurance programs, and financing stipulations or other
creditor concerns. Besides insurance, other risk mitigation measures include
improvements to physical asset resiliency and lease terms that transfer risk to tenants,
although these measures can create their own costs and risks for real estate entities. To
ensure long-term growth, entities must implement comprehensive climate change
adaptation strategies, account for trade-offs between various risk mitigation strategies,
and integrate all projected cost and benefit considerations over the long-term.
Metrics
IF-RE-450a.1. Area of properties located in 100-year flood zones, by property
sector
1
The entity shall disclose the total leasable floor area, in square metres, of
properties in the entity’s portfolio located in 100-year flood zones.
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
30
© IFRS Foundation
1.1
100-year flood zones are defined as land areas subject to a 1% or greater
chance of flooding in any given year. Such areas also may be referenced as
being subject to the 1% annual chance flood, the 1% annual exceedance
probability flood, or the 100-year flood.
1.1.1
Examples of 100-year flood zones may include coastal flood plains,
flood plains along major rivers and areas subject to flooding from
ponding in low-lying areas.
1.2
Number of units may be used in place of floor area in the Apartments and
Lodging/Resorts property sectors when floor area is not available.
2
The scope of disclosure shall include all the entity’s properties located in 100-year
flood zones, regardless of the jurisdiction in which they are located.
3
The entity shall disclose the total leasable floor area of properties that are located
in 100-year flood zones separately for each property type in its portfolio where
properties are classified into sectors aligned with the FTSE EPRA Nareit Global
Real Estate Index property sector classification.
4
The entity may separately provide the planned leasable floor area of properties
under development or construction that are located in 100-year flood zones.
5
The entity may disclose its risk perception and potential impacts resulting from
reclassification of 100-year flood zones, including the risk of expansion of such
areas into real estate property owned by the entity.
IF-RE-450a.2. Description of climate change risk exposure analysis, degree of
systematic portfolio exposure, and strategies for mitigating risks
1
The entity shall describe the significant risks and opportunities presented to its
business by climate change scenarios.
1.1
The entity shall identify each significant risk and opportunity.
1.1.1
Risks and opportunities may include availability of water, extreme
weather events, evolving regulation and legislation, impacts on
regional infrastructure, impacts on tenant demand, and impacts on
local economies and populations, regardless of the impact of
physical risks presented to the entity’s portfolio.
1.2
The entity shall discuss:
1.2.1
The time line over which such risks and opportunities are expected
to manifest.
1.2.2
How such climate change scenarios may manifest (for example,
effects directly on the entity or effects on the entity’s tenants).
1.2.3
How risks and opportunities may differ by property sector.
1.2.4
How risks and opportunities may differ by region.
1.3
The entity shall disclose the climate change scenarios used to determine
the risks and opportunities presented by climate change as defined by the
International Energy Agency in its annual World Energy Outlook.
IFRS S2 CLIMATE-RELATED DISCLOSURES–JUNE 2023
© IFRS Foundation
31
2
The entity shall describe efforts to assess and monitor the impacts of climate
change and the related strategies to alleviate or adapt to any risks or use any
opportunities.
2.1
Alleviation strategies may include the use of property insurance, flood
insurance, lease structures and lease durations.
2.2
Adaptation strategies may include investments in physical asset resiliency
and contingency plans.
2.3
The entity shall discuss:
2.3.1
How strategies may differ by property sector; and
2.3.2
How strategies may differ by region.
3
The discussion shall differentiate between physical asset risk and financial risk to
focus on the risks, opportunities, and alleviation or adaptation strategies that are
most likely to impact financial value.
IFRS S2 INDUSTRY-BASED GUIDANCE
32
© IFRS Foundation
© IFRS Foundation
33
Columbus Building
7 Westferry Circus
Canary Wharf
London E14 4HD, UK
Tel
+44 (0) 20 7246 6410
Email sustainability_licensing@ifrs.org
ifrs.org
International Financial Reporting Standards®, IFRS Foundation®,
IFRS®, IAS®, IFRIC®, SIC®, IASB®, ISSBTM, IFRS for SMEs®
版本与出处
- Volume 36—Real Estate